Dear Sir Letters, the terraces, the panel and the Rumour Mill
Letters to the Editor
Dear Sir
Write to the Pink
The letters page belongs to the readers. A line on today's game, a grievance with the referee, a memory of the old ground: the best are printed here next Saturday, with your name and your club.
Write your letter at thefootballpink.com/letters →
Every letter is read before it is printed. Keep it under 200 words.
The Pink's Call
Pink's Call
Close isn't a cap, Thomas
Thomas Tuchel left Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall out of England's squad on Friday morning and called him "close". By Friday night the Everton midfielder had an assist, a goal and three points. That is not a man who needs another lecture about where he fits on a tactics board.
Tuchel's explanation was neat enough. "I don't see him in central midfield — more as an eight or a 10, in the finishing part of the game," he told the BBC. "The competition is very, very high in our squad in this position." Dewsbury-Hall was in the World Cup 55. He is "very close". Fine. Close does not get you a seat on the plane to Croatia.
What happened next is the bit England should actually study. Dewsbury-Hall crossed for Thierno Barry's equaliser against Coventry, then finished the night himself from a tight angle after Barry's through ball. Sky Sports noted it as a response to the snub. It looked like a midfielder who finishes games, which is rather the role Tuchel says he wants.
England's midfield is stacked. Nobody is arguing for a free pass. But form is form, and Everton have climbed into fifth with Dewsbury-Hall central to it. If the threshold is "finishing part of the game", Friday night was a case study. If the threshold is club badge and reputation, say so.
The Pink's call: watch the tape, not the role chart. Cap the players who are deciding Premier League matches in November. "Very close" is a compliment. A call-up is a decision.
Facts from BBC Sport, Sky Sports. Opinion is the Pink's own.
The Pools Panel
What the chances said should have happened, from expected goals (xG) in the match data, against what did. The panel agreed with 4 of 8 results.
| Match | xG | Panel | Result | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arsenal 1-0 Hull City | 1.3-0.4 | Home | Home | ✓ |
| Fulham 1-1 Newcastle | 0.8-1.2 | Away | Draw | ✗ |
| Birmingham 2-1 Swansea | 3.0-1.1 | Home | Home | ✓ |
| Cardiff 5-4 Burnley | 4.7-2.4 | Home | Home | ✓ |
| Preston 1-0 Southampton | 1.4-1.9 | Away | Home | ✗ |
| QPR 2-1 Lincoln | 1.8-1.5 | Draw | Home | ✗ |
| Watford 0-0 Middlesbrough | 0.4-2.0 | Away | Draw | ✗ |
| West Brom 3-0 Millwall | 3.0-0.4 | Home | Home | ✓ |